Drake Bell's character did not appear in the segment.
Plot[]
The introductions begin as Amber says her name is Amber and she reveals that if they look up "popular" in the dictionary, they will find her, then Sheila says her name is Sheila and she angrily asks that anybody has a problem with that, then Tammy says that her name is Tammy and she is an exchange student from Tennessee, then finally, Debbie says that her name is Elizabeth, but Amber corrects her by saying that Debbie’s name is Debbie. After the introductions from the girls, the group reveals it’s Amber's birthday. Debbie, Tammy and Sheila each give Amber a gift.
Debbie gives Amber the first gift. Sheila reminds Amber to open the gift before Debbie, whom Sheila calls "Elizabeth", pushes Sheila over the edge. Amber opens a carton of eggs though she finds one missing. Debbie is then revealed to have the missing egg claiming he’s so cute before saying it’s a girl.
Tammy then reveals that she has a fake birthday cake with a guy (Josh Peck) in a fireman costume. He then takes off his coat and hat and performs a suggestive dance which he goes overboard on and Amber tells him to stop it. As he does not listen to Amber and Sheila and Tammy and Debbie, he performs one last move and the girls yell at him to stop. Sheila then goes and gives the guy a swirlie. Shortly after, Tammy and Amber bid the guy goodbye before he leaves.
It’s now time for Sheila to show what her present is. Sheila says she hopes Amber likes it. Before this happens, Danielle Spencer comes into the bathroom and walks to the mirrors. Tammy and Amber aren’t pleased to see Danielle being in the bathroom and the latter asks what’s she doing here. Danielle simply says she has much right to come into the bathroom as they are. Debbie compliments Danielle on her dress. Danielle says she should because it costs over $300. Amber isn’t happy about this. Danielle then walks over to Sheila and tells her " 'Scuse me, won't you?" before going into the bathroom stall that has a "Happy Birthday" sign on the front. After a moment, Sheila throws away the gift she’s holding and says she just found Amber a better gift and tells her that she’ll be right back then Sheila goes into the bathroom stall and takes the expensive dress off Danielle and gives it to Amber, leaving Danielle in her slip.
Signing off the show, Amber says that she is popular, Tammy says that she is Southern, Sheila says that she is attitudinal, and Debbie says that she is Elizabeth. Amber, Sheila, and Tammy correct Debbie by using her name "Debbie!" Debbie says that she likes eggs.